There are two ways to stop insurance junk mail: one free request that stops prescreened offers made from your credit report, and a direct request to the few insurers with their own form.
The quick answer
- Go to optoutprescreen.com (type it yourself) and opt out of prescreened credit and insurance offers: five years online, or permanently with a signed form.
- Use the insurer’s own form where there is one: GEICO, Liberty Mutual and State Farm, below.
- Keep a screenshot of each request.
Insurers with their own opt-out
- GEICO: web form, and you don’t need to be a policyholder.
- Liberty Mutual: its own removal site; it says to allow 8 to 12 weeks.
- State Farm: Do Not Solicit form, or a letter.
Insurers without an online or mail route
On Progressive’s, Allstate’s, Farmers’, Nationwide’s and USAA’s own sites, we couldn’t find a web form, email address or mailing address for stopping their marketing mail. The OptOutPrescreen request still stops their prescreened offers.
Good to know
- Already a customer? Your own insurer can still mail you after an OptOutPrescreen request. Ask it directly.
- OptOutPrescreen covers offers made from credit reports. Ads addressed to “Current Resident” or “Postal Customer” aren’t covered.
- Want our full guide to card and insurance offers? Start here.
Sources
- FTC, How to stop junk mail: OptOutPrescreen.com, run by the major credit bureaus, stops prescreened credit and insurance offers; five years online or permanently with a signed form.
- GEICO, Liberty Mutual and State Farm: linked from each guide.
- Progressive, Allstate, Farmers, Nationwide and USAA privacy pages, read November 4, 2026: no web, email or mail route for stopping marketing mail found. Last checked November 4, 2026.
Mail for someone who doesn’t live with you? Here’s what to do → · More companies →
Or let us handle it
Snap a photo of the mail you don’t want. Mailbox Zero prepares each request, asks you once, then checks that the mail actually stopped.
Free to start · Pilot opens this winter · No card today
You’re on the list
Mailbox Zero is independent and not affiliated with Lands’ End or the U.S. Postal Service.
